[lbo-talk] Marriage and Prostitution

ravi gadfly at exitleft.org
Tue May 10 19:40:37 PDT 2005


Doug Henwood wrote:
> Yeah. Being a "prole" isn't just about your income - it's whether you
> give or take orders on the job, how much control you have, the kinds of
> decisions you make, etc. In that sense, nurses are echt proles.
>

from fussell ('class'):

It's down among the mod- and low-proles that features some might find offensive begin to show themselves. These are the people who feel bitter about their work, often because they are closely supervised and regulated and generally treated like wayward children. Andrew Levison, author of The Working-Class Majority, invites us to imagine what it would be like to be under the constant eye of a foreman, "a figure who has absolutely no counterpart in middle-class society. Salaried professionals do often have people above them, but it is impossible to imagine professors or executives being required to bring a doctor's note if they are absent a day or having to justify the number of trips they take to the bathroom". Mid- and low proles are perceived to be so because they perform the role of the victims in that "coercive utilization of man by man" that Veblen found so objectionable. (pp47-48)

A taxi driver in St.Louis defended the Vietnam War by saying, "We can't be a pitiful, helpless giant. We gotta show 'em we're number one". "Are you number one?" Studs Terkel asked him. Pause. "I'm number nothin'," he said.

--ravi



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list