[lbo-talk] The STFU left

Michael Pugliese michael.098762001 at gmail.com
Sun May 22 19:30:42 PDT 2005


Ah me being a provocateur to Charles...and Justin by forwarding the Stephen Schwartz, red-diaper baby (Mom was CPUSA), later neo-Trotskyist, then back to the CPUSA, now neo-con as y'all know.

Right-wingers send me stuff too, to convert me to neo-connery, and I don't get all defensive about it. Why? A good debate from an ideological adversary, far to my Right, is as fun and productive to honing my pov on the Left, as debates intra-left, are. And from Rightists I have heard of many texts like say, The aelth and Poverty of Nations, " by Landes I intend to read as I re-read Samir Amin and Andrew Gunder Frank.

Charles, you will never do, what you should do and read Trotskyist and libertarian socialist texts that critique your dinosaurism. MG has it exactly right, anti-Stalinist leftists criticize the USSR/ fSU (and I have long thought, in self-critique that Trot, Menshevik or libertarian socialists cnn tend towards a metaphysical idealism though) on socialist, communist, marxist, radical democratic grounds. Reactionary? Save me the CPUSA boilerplate I have seen a zillion times in pamphlets from International Publishers from the 30's. Guess I shou;d be glad you don't quoye Vyshinsky and just call Trotskyists and Bukharinites "fascists" and dogs.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list