[lbo-talk] Walmart flak Andy Young joins the Gibson-Allen brigade

ylle521 at highstream.net ylle521 at highstream.net
Sat Aug 19 13:05:08 PDT 2006


Yay, Doug. This brouhaha with Young prompted me to go looking for writings on Wal-Mart and I was reading some of your spouse's stuff earlier today. She's the only journalist that I know of who actually has some understanding and compassion for the low-income people who patronize WMT and get by that much easier on little money. I appreciated her quoting a Wal-Mart customer's letter to the editor in a community Wal-Mart was looking to enter; when told that the pay for full-time workers there was as little as $15,000 a year, she responded that she didn't think that was such a bad income, compared to how poor she and others she knows are. Another woman chimed in, that her income is half of that, that 15 grand a year would be great!

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20050103/featherstone

Does that make Wally World suck any less? Of course not. But it's been my observation that the Wal-Mart battle lines are clearly divided by class; referring again to the editorial page, last year there was organized opposition to building another one around here, and a letter in the local rag put it vividly, if crudely, calling the anti-Wal-Mart leaders "boutique bitches".

Liza F. highlights the fact that the root of this is the way Americans (with the rest of the world is catching up with us) see themselves as not workers or citizens but mere consumers, who can make only consumer decisions and actions and don't really see a role in life beyond that. Typical Americans are so craven (how else can you describe it?), they've been willing to work like world-class galley slaves, hold down multiple jobs, send all the adults out into the workforce, have little time and energy to raise their kids, get zero help from the govt unless you're destitute and even that help is given grudgingly, and allow the powers-that-be to utterly screw them by rejecting political struggle instead of embracing it as a citizen would because: quite frankly, *they can't imagine living any other way.* Doing anything that could risk reducing your capacity to consume is like something from another dimension: it's not just threatening, it's inconceivable.

Maria


>Young's remarks were stupid, but they obscured a valid point - poor
>people pay small businesses enormous markups at retail, and Wal-Mart
>offers some relief from that. Of course, WMT's employment practices
>suck, but if you're a poor person, you might welcome some
>alternative to the petit bourgeois on the corner.
>
>Doug
>
>___________________________________
>http://mailman.lbo-talk.org/mailman/listinfo/lbo-talk



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list