[lbo-talk] eminent domain

joanna 123hop at comcast.net
Thu Feb 23 16:19:17 PST 2006


Doug Henwood wrote:


>> Fuck, I'm not against eminent domain for real public improvement
>> purposes, but I think those should be narrowly defined. Awful things
>> have gone on in the name of urban planning; we've just heard some
>> examples from LA, and I know of plenty from NYC and New Haven (the
>> laboratory for urban renewal). There's a real prob with eminent
>> domain as it's actually practiced, and it's not just right-wing
>> cynics playing on crude populist sentiments.
>
Exactly, and note that "improvement" in eminent domain cases is often synonymous with profit-making ability. Yet who is to say that store A, making 2X profit is better than store B, making X profit?

It seems to me that the survival of the most profitable is not a desirable principle.

Joanna


>>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list