Social movements (was Re: [lbo-talk] DIY abortions)

Chuck chuck at mutualaid.org
Thu Mar 2 14:30:26 PST 2006


Marvin Gandall wrote:
> Wojtek and Chuck - the most unlikely of bedfellows - are united in
> building
> an iron wall between political action and social action. Most everyone else
> would say you have to engage in both, that these are complementary rather
> than contradictory forms of protest. Demonstrations and other mass actions
> are necessary to give people confidence in their collective strength;
> political action is necessary to give effect to their demands, typically
> through legislation. We may, and often do, disagree on what are appropriate
> tactics in both arenas, but I don't think anyone on this list would elevate
> one as a "principle" to the exclusion of the other - except Chuck, who has
> an anarchist's hostilty to participation in the bourgeois political system,
> and Wojtek, who has a genteel conservative's repugnance for the "thuggish
> multitudes" and what they can accomplish in the streets.
>
> Given their present views, I'd want neither leading my army or my trade
> union, although they both strike me as bright and engaging people. I'd be
> worried that Wojtek would always be counselling retreat and Chuck would
> always be urging an assault, and that neither would ever take into account

Ah yes, nothing like the cartoon version of my actual politics.

Ridiculous nonsense.

Chuck



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list