>my own experience tells me that 'lefty' anti-union attitudes are often held
>by folks who have little actual experience - warts and all - with unions
>themselves...
I don't have much, aside from the dismal National Writers Union, but Fitch has plenty. First joined one at age 15 (Laborers, in Chicago). Worked for Musicians Local 802 as an organizer, and CWA Local 1180 as a policy guy. He's spent lots of time studying the inner working of DC 37 in New York, too. And he's been covering unions as a journalist for almost 20 years.
I could turn this around and say that lots of left intellectuals and academics have a romantic idea of unions, and are unacquainted with the warts.
Doug