-B.
The Red and the Black
[...]
People shouldnt be afraid of their governments governments should be afraid of their people.
V for Vendetta may be--why hedge? is--the most subversive cinematic deed of the Bush-Blair era, a dagger poised in midair. Unlike the other movies dubbed controversial (Fahrenheit 9-11, The Passion, Munich, Syriana), it doesnt play to a particular constituency or polarized culture bloc, its working on a deeper, Edger Allen Poe-ish witchs brew substrata of pop myth.
Cultural conservatives will loathe it without seeing it (they love not having to leave their houses to lament the latest installment of civilizations decline and fall) once they hear of and read about the movies disturbing political parallels (a fascistic TV host with a witty resemblance to Berlusconi, fertilizer explosives a la Timothy McVeigh; torture, renditions, and subway bombings; black hoods that will be forever associated with Abu Ghraib). Yet lots of cultural liberals with educated tastes will find it anxiety-producing and irresponsible too, not only because theyre more comfortable with humanistic stories and documentary techniques than with pop spectacle (as Kael discovered whenever she praised upstart movies like DePalmas Carrie or The Warriors and received letters from profs and Ph.D couples complaining about her soiling the New Yorkers space on trash), but because V for Vendetta doesnt just depict a 1984s dystopia--it advocates radical remedy, and illustrates what it advocates with rhapsodic, operatic, orgasmic flourish.
[...]
http://jameswolcott.com/archives/2006/02/the_red_and_the.php