[lbo-talk] A highly critical take on Fitch

Carrol Cox cbcox at ilstu.edu
Tue Mar 14 10:20:19 PST 2006


Marvin Gandall wrote:
>
> Certainly, the
> indictment of his critics is that he has drawn a one-sided and misleading
> picture of US labour - one resembling the caricature of it by the right. If
> this is so, in Fitch's case would be unintentional, but it would flow from
> the same questionable starting point where much of the left begins its
> analysis: that all contemporary problems are reducible to deficient leaders
> in the unions and the mass parties who are seen as somehow at odds with
> their members, when, in fact, it is conditions which produce leaders who,
> for the most part, reflect the consciousness and values of their base.

This emphasis on leadership tends to characterize many followers of Trotsky, as well as those who worry about who the DP will nominate in 2008, but is it really widespread enough to justify your phrase, "much of the left"? I don't think so.

Carrol



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list