[lbo-talk] More on L.A.'s "biggest public protest in its history"

JC Helary jch.helary at free.fr
Mon Mar 27 02:10:10 PST 2006



> "undocumented immigrant workers"?
> Why not just say "illegal immigrants"?

Because "illegal" encompases "illegal labor" and "illegal status". In the case of illegal labor, the worker is mostly the victim and thus "illegal" should generally limited to "status". Still, a status is only a matter of procedure and has nothing to do with criminality or delinquency, thus using "undocumented" is prefered to "illegal".

It is very easy to slip from an "irregular status" to criminality in politician lingo. Keeping facts straight helps seeing the reality migrants are facing.

At least that is my understanding.

Jean-Christophe Helary



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list