[lbo-talk] defining terms (was RE: trash talking the lumpenproletariat)

[Nick C. Woomer-Deters]

...It's not just the education system either.  The poor in the United States
are subject to a variety of institutions that foster a kind of childlike
dependence, where they're put at the mercy of the arbitrary whims of the
bureaucracy and where you're most likely to succeed if you internalize
reactive thinking.  I suppose that after 18 years of this, where you only
gain anything by doing what other people tell you to do -- and you live in a
community comprised of similarly-situated individuals -- the capacity for
deliberative thinking is just totally crippled.  Is it any wonder, then,
that this process often produces people who are totally incapable of
thinking more than a few days ahead?

To bring in another example, while there's a lot of talk about the
unprecedented size of the U.S. prison and jail population, the population on
parole or probation is simply staggering
(http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/glance/corr2.htm
).  Many people don't realize how difficult probation and parole is: there
are random drug and alcohol tests, you have to make sure you keep in touch
with your probation officer (much harder than it sounds), clear any travel
with him/her, demonstrate that you're working to find a job and pleasing
your boss, etc.  In my experience, roughly 5-10 percent of defendants find
probation so burdensome, they'll elect to serve the rest of their sentences
in prison or jail rather than worry about pleasing their probation officer
(who has the power to find them in violation of the terms of parole and send
them back to prison).

It's a false choice between allocating social resources to the desperately
poor and encouraging personal autonomy, self-reliance and deliberative
thought but, of course, such an approach is liable to encourage uppity-ness.

-N
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <../attachments/20061112/d2fe74cf/attachment.htm>