[lbo-talk] More than Devilish

Dwayne Monroe idoru345 at yahoo.com
Tue Oct 3 09:08:03 PDT 2006


Andy F:

While I see the value of having the torturer pull the electrodes and pliars out of the closet and proudly hold them up for all the world to see, I can't shake the feeling that a line has been crossed, and that we're a long way from bottoming out.

........................

In March of 2003, Zizek argued that the central problem we confront is the creation of new authoritarian norms:

excerpted from <http://www.lacan.com/iraq.htm>

THE IRAQ WAR: WHERE IS THE TRUE DANGER?

<snip>

The true danger can be best exemplified by the actual role of the populist Right in Europe: to introduce certain topics (the foreign threat, the necessity to limit immigration, etc.) which were then silently taken over not only by the conservative parties, but even by the de facto politics of the "Socialist" governments. Today, the need to "regulate" the status of immigrants, etc., is part of the mainstream consensus: as the story goes, le Pen did address and exploit real problems which bother people. One is almost tempted to say that, if there were no le Pen in France, he should have been invented: he is a perfect person whom one loves to hate, the hatred for whom guarantees the wide liberal "democratic pact," the pathetic identification with democratic values of tolerance and respect for diversity - however, after shouting "Horrible! How dark and uncivilized! Wholly unacceptable! A threat to our basic democratic values!", the outraged liberals proceed to act like "le Pen with a human face," to do the same thing in a more "civilized" way, along the lines of "But the racist populists are manipulating legitimate worries of ordinary people, so we do have to take some measures!"...

We do have here a kind of perverted Hegelian "negation of negation": in a first negation, the populist Right disturbs the aseptic liberal consensus by giving voice to passionate dissent, clearly arguing against the "foreign threat"; in a second negation, the "decent" democratic center, in the very gesture of pathetically rejecting this populist Right, integrates its message in a "civilized" way - in-between, the ENTIRE FIELD of background "unwritten rules" has already changed so much that no one even notices it and everyone is just relieved that the anti-democratic threat is over. And the true danger is that something similar will happen with the "war on terror": "extremists" like John Ashcroft will be discarded, but their legacy will remain, imperceptibly interwoven into the invisible ethical fabric of our societies. Their defeat will be their ultimate triumph: they will no longer be needed, since their message will be incorporated into the mainstream.

...

.d.

How should you approach life? Like a samurai, ready for death at any time.

Pater Monroe, 1978 ...................... http://monroelab.net/blog/



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list