[lbo-talk] Let's Build

Wojtek Sokolowski sokol at jhu.edu
Mon Oct 16 08:42:22 PDT 2006


How about dispersal of the means of production and rationally planned production for use and need with a view towards beauty while "living in harmony with the Earth". Salmon in the Thames!

Regards,

Mike B)

[WS:] Was it not a way the ruling classes wanted to deal with the growing "threat" of labor militancy - through geographical dispersed housing projects? If memory serves, Le Corbusier even designed one, and Nixon claimed that suburbanization of America will finish off communism. He was certainly right.

I think that American suburbia are probably one of the most sterile, aesthetically uninspiring and alienating landscapes ever created, perhaps on a par with Soviet-style housing projects. However, the deciding factor in people's attitudes toward this form of settlement is not efficiency, functionality or aesthetic but "hard-wired" cognitive perceptions of space. Those who are hard wired for open, scarcely populated spaces will feel miserable in the most functional and efficient urban setting; while those hard wired for closed densely populated spaces will always be miserable in the country side, even if they lived in mansions. These preferences are like claustrophobia or agoraphobia - they cannot be rationally debated.

Personally, I feel miserable in open, sparsely populated places. This is true not just about human settlements but natural landscape as well - I feel better in a dense forest than on an open plain - which is probably an agoraphobic tendency. So obviously, I am biased against suburban and rural settlements. But having acknowledged my bias, I have a simple question that can be answered in a matter of fact manner. How can they fit 6+ billion people in a landscape modeled on the US suburbia? Or is it going to be "fenced in open spaces" for the selected few, while the riff raff will be keep at bay by gunboats and fenced borders?

Wojtek

-------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <../attachments/20061016/93876658/attachment.htm>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list