September 30, 2006 Books of The Times
A Portrait of Bush as a Victim of His Own Certitude
By MICHIKO KAKUTANI
In Bob Woodwards highly anticipated new book, State of Denial, President Bush emerges as a passive, impatient, sophomoric and intellectually incurious leader, presiding over a grossly dysfunctional war cabinet and given to an almost religious certainty that makes him disinclined to rethink or re-evaluate decisions he has made about the war. ...
Startlingly little of this overall picture is new, of course. ... But if much of State of Denial simply ratifies the larger outline of the Bush administrations bungled handling of the war as laid out by other reporters, Mr. Woodward does flesh out that narrative with new illustrations and some telling details that enrich the readers understanding of the inner workings of this administration at this critical moment.
He reports, for instance, that the Vietnam-era Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger had a powerful, largely invisible influence on the foreign policy of the Bush administration, urging President Bush and Vice President Cheney to stick it out. According to Mr. Woodward, Mr. Kissinger gave the former Bush adviser and speechwriter Michael Gerson his so-called 1969 salted peanut memo, which warned President Richard M. Nixon that withdrawal of U.S. troops will become like salted peanuts to the American public; the more U.S. troops come home, the more will be demanded.
As with Mr. Woodwards earlier books, many of his interviews were conducted on background, though, from the point of view of particular passages, its often easy for the reader to figure out just who his sources were. In some cases he recreates conversations seemingly based on interviews with only one of the participants. The former Saudi Arabian ambassador Prince Bandar bin Sultan, Mr. Card, Mr. Tenet, Deputy Secretary of State Richard L. Armitage and Brent Scowcroft, the former national security adviser (to Bush senior), appear to be among the authors primary sources.
Whereas Mr. Woodward has tended in the past to stand apart from his narrative, rarely pausing to analyze or assess the copious material he has gathered, he is more of an active agent in this volume perhaps in a kind of belated mea culpa for his earlier positive portrayals of the administration. In particular, he inserts himself into interviews with Mr. Rumsfeld clearly annoyed, even appalled, by the Pentagon chiefs cavalier language and reluctance to assume responsibility for his departments failures.
Mr. Woodward reports that when he told Mr. Rumsfeld that the number of insurgent attacks was going up, the defense secretary replied that theyre now categorizing more things as attacks. Mr. Woodward quotes Mr. Rumsfeld as saying, A random round can be an attack and all the way up to killing 50 people someplace. So youve got a whole fruit bowl of different things a banana and an apple and an orange.
Mr. Woodward adds: I was speechless. Even with the loosest and most careless use of language and analogy, I did not understand how the secretary of defense would compare insurgent attacks to a fruit bowl, a metaphor that stripped them of all urgency and emotion. The official categories in the classified reports that Rumsfeld regularly received were the lethal I.E.D.s, standoff attacks with mortars and close engagements such as ambushes.
Earlier in the volume, in a section describing the former Iraq administrator Jay Garners reluctance to tell the president about the mistakes he saw the Pentagon making in Iraq, Mr. Woodward writes: It was only one example of a visitor to the Oval Office not telling the president the whole story or the truth. Likewise, in these moments where Bush had someone from the field there in the chair beside him, he did not press, did not try to open the door himself and ask what the visitor had seen and thought. The whole atmosphere too often resembled a royal court, with Cheney and Rice in attendance, some upbeat stories, exaggerated good news and a good time had by all. Were the war in Iraq not a real war that has resulted in more than 2,700 American military casualties and more than 56,000 Iraqi civilian deaths, the picture of the Bush administration that emerges from this book might resemble a farce. Its like something out of The Daily Show or a Saturday Night Live sketch, with Freudian Bush family dramas and high-school-like rivalries between cabinet members who refuse to look at one another at meetings being played out on the world stage.
Theres the president, who once said, I dont have the foggiest idea about what I think about international, foreign policy, deciding that hes going to remake the Middle East and alter the course of American foreign policy. Theres his father, former President George Herbert Walker Bush (who went to war against the same country a decade ago), worrying about the wisdom of another war but reluctant to offer his opinions to his son because he believes in the principle of let him be himself. Theres the presidents national security adviser whining to him that the defense secretary wont return her phone calls. And theres the president and Karl Rove, his chief political adviser, trading fart jokes. ...
******************************************
[lbo-talk] pull my finger Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com Wed Aug 23 16:26:45 PDT 2006
On Aug 22, 2006, at 7:38 PM, Dennis Claxton wrote:
>from U.S. News and World Report, by way of Cursor:
>
>He loves to cuss, gets a jolly when a mountain biker wipes out trying to
>keep up with him, and now we're learning that the first frat boy loves
>flatulence jokes. A top insider let that slip when explaining why
>President Bush is paranoid around women, always worried about his
>behavior. But he's still a funny, earthy guy who, for example, can't get
>enough of fart jokes. He's also known to cut a few for laughs, especially
>when greeting new young aides, but forget about getting people to gas
>about that.
>
>http://www.usnews.com/usnews/politics/whispers/articles/
>060820/28whisplead.htm
Reminiscent of Brendan Gill's story, retold by Alexander Cockburn, about visiting the Bush family compound in Kennebunkport, and wandering around sleeplessly one night, and finding the only available book to be a collection of fart jokes.
******************************************
Carl