[lbo-talk] IWW piece on Iranian labor situation

Yoshie Furuhashi critical.montages at gmail.com
Thu Apr 19 10:12:01 PDT 2007


On 4/19/07, Wojtek Sokolowski <sokol at jhu.edu> wrote:
> Yoshie:
>
> Compare Japan -- its wealth, living standard, etc. -- with any former
> colony of any empire, including Japan's own. It seems clear to me
> that getting colonized by a capitalist empire is not a good deal
> compared to not getting colonized by one. It shouldn't take a Marxist
> to understand that.
>
> [WS:] I am glad that you mentioned Japan. It developed during the Meji
> Restoration, which was wholesale copying of Western organizational forms
> (cartels) and technologies. Cross national "borrowing" of Western
> institutions and technologies was by far the main form of influence.

Japan is a good example that demonstrates this fact: the domestic ruling class who develop capitalism and modernity on their own, their power elites importing some cultural and scientific products of other nations at their convenience while rejecting others* at will, perform far better than the foreign ruling classes of empires that delay and deform development of capitalism in the hinterlands of their respective realms through colonialism and imperialism.

* Japan's ruling class, in the process of developing their capitalism and modernity, were far more xenophobic than any Third World revolutionary, socialist or capitalist or Islamist. Sakoku (limiting the trade with the West), fumie (a method of identifying Christians in order to persecute them), and so on all helped fend off would-be colonizers and fostered Japan's economic development, without which it could have turned into just another underdeveloped former Asian colony of a Western empire. Really, no matter how hard you try, it's impossible to sell the Japanese on the virtue of getting colonized, though the Right in Japan are no doubt as sure as you of the virtues of dominating others and helping America dominate others, both of which have added to Japan's economic development. -- Yoshie



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list