[lbo-talk] Marx and Justice

[B.]

So this is a debate that is still going on in Marxist
circles even though the Allen Wood vs. Ziyad Husami
documents I have on, it in book form, from the 1970s,
are at least 30 years old? (And Husami seems to "win,"
if you ask me, in refuting Wood.)

That is depressing. It's kind of like poring over Old
Testament documents for crossed t's and dotted i's.

I guess everyone has their hobby.

-B.

Rakesh Bhandari wrote:

"The well respected political philosopher Jonathan
Wolff lays out Allen Wood's argument that Marx did not
condemn capitalist as unjust. Of course Wood agrees
that Marx criticized it on other grounds. See Wolff's
thesis 23. And where the heck has the internationally
recognized expert Andie been in this discussion? http://www.homepages.ucl.ac.uk/~uctyjow/Long%20Handout.htm"