[lbo-talk] globo & culture

Yoshie Furuhashi critical.montages at gmail.com
Fri Feb 23 16:39:33 PST 2007


On 2/22/07, Sean Andrews <cultstud76 at gmail.com> wrote:
> So, in these examples above, because local culture is currently more
> popular in these areas and because these areas are
> (Malthusian moment)
> experiencing econmic growth which will lead to population growth,
> which, assuming the long term stability of current cultural
> conditions, will mean that American Culture will not be popular.
> Except for one kind of culture: I'm going to a talk this afternoon
> with Andrew Ross who's been doing ethnographic research in China for
> the past few years. One of the interesting things he finds in his
> discussions with young people is that they actually read a lot of
> American "literature:"
>
> In his book /Fast Boat to China/ he talks about teens in the library
> "scanning the /Wall Street Journal/ or cramming business or management
> textbooks. Business literature was widely read among Shainghainese
> youth, more voraciously than any other Western popular culture, though
> self help-literature--from classics like Dale Carnegie to
> more-contemporary volumes like Stephen Covey's /The 7 Habits of Highly
> Effective People/, or Laurie Beth Jones' Christian-based /The Power of
> Positive Prophecy/--was gaining ground" (107-108)

The most important question about culture and imperialism is probably not what masses consume (for masses, save under exceptionally turbulent circumstances, have a hard time exercising hegemony over the political economy of their respective nations under capitalism or state socialism) as what the power elite, and elite workers who culturally, politically, or administratively serve the power elite, consume, say, the top 20% of a nation in the South and the top 30-40% of a nation in the North. If you win their hearts and minds, you may be certain that they will run their country in a way that will not hurt your interests, whatever the lower orders think, though it will help if they, too, like you, which will diminish the likelihood of unpleasant surprises.

A Mexican director may win an Oscar, but education in American capitalism has certainly been winning the highest political office in Mexico since 1982:

Felipe Calderón (2006-Present), Master's in Public Administration, Harvard University Vicente Fox (2000-2006), attended classes at Harvard University and worked for Coca Cola Ernesto Zedillo (1994-2000), Ph.D. in Economics, Yale University Carlos Salinas (1988-1994), Master's in Public Administration, Master's in Economics, Ph.D. in Economics, Harvard University Miguel de la Madrid (1982-1988), Master's in Public Administration, Harvard University

Mexico (like Panama and the Philippines), to be sure, is probably one of the most extreme examples, but it is certainly worth looking into the education in particular and culture in general of the power elite and classes and strata that produce them in each nation.


>> New York Times - February 22, 2007
>> <http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/22/business/22scene.html>
>>
>> Some Countries Remain Resistant to American Cultural Exports
>> By TYLER COWEN
>>
>> American movies and music have done very well in some countries like
>> Sweden and less well in others like India. This may sound like a
>> simple difference in human tastes, but decisions to consume culture
>> have an economic aspect.
>
> Notice, of course, setting the whole stage for his argument that 1.
> this is relevant to for economists to consider and 2. the question of
> culture is about "choice" and "consumption"

Also, we should delve into the content of those local products and see whether they convey alternative visions to the American dream of capitalism . . . and whether some of them don't sell capitalism in a way that would make Hollywood blush.

E.g.,

Milind Wani, Manju Menon, and Kanchi Kohli, "Picturing Reality," a review of Guru (Dir. Mani Ratnam, 2007), whose hero's goal is to make his company the biggest in the world, <http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/wmk150207.html>.

Aarti Wani, "Uses of History: Rang De Basanti and Lage Raho Munnabhai," <http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/wani120207.html>. -- Yoshie <http://montages.blogspot.com/> <http://mrzine.org> <http://monthlyreview.org/>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list