[lbo-talk] Marxism and Religion

Yoshie Furuhashi critical.montages at gmail.com
Mon Feb 26 07:25:55 PST 2007


On 2/26/07, B. <docile_body at yahoo.com> wrote:
> Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:
>
> "Make workers (relatively) really rich by the world
> standard, and they will be probably less religious,
> but that works only for native-born workers of the
> North, and that doesn't seem to motivate them to
> socialism or communism."
>
>
> Me:
>
> Maybe. According to the Cambridge Companion to Atheism
> (2005), though, quite a number of the world's poorer
> countries are very atheist -- Vietnam beats the US,
> France, Norway, and others. Even Armenia beat the USA.
> In a Top 50 list, number 1 being most religious, 50
> being least, America was number 44, and more atheist
> than it were countries like Uruguay, North Korea,
> Kazakhstan, Mongolia, Czech Republic, etc. Ironically,
> Cuba was no. 49, barely in the Top 50:
>
> http://www.pitzer.edu/academics/faculty/zuckerman/atheism.html
>
> (Methodology of survey is there.)

Viet Nam seems to be going as capitalist as China (where religion appears to be growing fast, Chinese workers and peasants undoubtedly in need of a lot of the opium of the people as an antidote to the pain of transition to capitalism), as Ulhas tirelessly reminds us. Official atheism of nominally socialist and communist parties don't appear to do much in motivating people to socialism or communism in substance.

To be sure, some of the Communist Party members in Viet Nam, China, etc. may _sincerely_ believe that they are indirectly building socialism by fostering more and more of capitalist development. But that seems to me to be a bigger illusion than belief in the efficacy of prayers. :->

That is not surprising -- communism can be the opium of the people, as some people of faith apparently realized:

<http://www.marxists.org/archive/chamberlin-william/1929/soviet-russia/ch13.htm> William Henry Chamberlin | Soviet Russia: A Living Record and a History THE STRUGGLE FOR THE RUSSIAN SOUL

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

This struggle for the Russian soul between the Communists, with their goal of a new society in which religion shall have no place, and the Orthodox Church, the sectarians, Orthodox Jews, and Mohammedans, each group offering some special appeal to its own worshipers, is one of the most complicated and interesting of the psychological dramas which are being enacted in the Soviet Union to-day. The struggle is symbolized in one of the main squares of Moscow, where, on a brick building, opposite the famous shrine of the Iberian Virgin,(2) were inscribed the words: "Religion is opium for the people."

In many a worker's home one can find similar evidences of this struggle. In one corner of the room the wife continues to burn candles before the traditional Russian ikons, or carved images representing Jesus, the Virgin Mary, and scenes from the Bible and the lives of the saints. In another place the Communist husband has arranged his "Lenin corner," strikingly and suggestively similar to the ikon corner in general idea, with the pictures of Lenin from childhood to death, portraits of other Communist leaders, and a few Communist books and pamphlets.

I once stood in a factory church which had been turned into a workers' club; and here again the substitution of new objects of reverence for old was very striking. Instead of pictures of the saints, pictures of Marx and Lenin. Instead of the rich decorations of the typical Orthodox church, red streamers pro-claiming that with Communism would come the final liberation of humanity. An adherent of the Russian church with whom I talked once said: -

"The Communists say that religion is opium for the people. But we can say, with much more reason, that Communism is opium for the people." -- Yoshie <http://montages.blogspot.com/> <http://mrzine.org> <http://monthlyreview.org/>



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list