Purer Than Thou (Was Re: [lbo-talk] Obama 'was educatedinmadrassa')

Dwayne Monroe idoru345 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 22 09:58:01 PST 2007


Wojtek:

There were many social movements in the 19th century seeking a betterment of the working class - utopian, mutualist, religious, luddite, or even reactionary. But the Marxist brand of socialism was unique thanks to their master theory. This is what I am asking for - not a laundry list of what needs to change, no matter how justified.

....................

But perhaps the time for a socialist "master theory" has passed. Or, alternatively, the master theories are out there -- in either complete or nascent form -- but aren't easily recognizable as "socialist" because the old language isn't employed.

Here's your description of a sensible course of action:

A rational person in that situation [seeing problems with the real world implementation of some of Marx's ideas] would return to the drawing board, examine the past experience, get rid of what did not work or became obsolete, retained what was still usable, develop a new goal, realistically asses the chances of its implementation, and on those grounds devise a new strategy. This is what engineers do when their design malfunctions or crashes*).

[...]

And like a good engineer who abandons a faulty design, it may be time for you to discard your dream of a new "master theory".

.d.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list