[lbo-talk] cruise report (FDR, tough guy)

bhandari at berkeley.edu bhandari at berkeley.edu
Tue Jul 31 00:37:48 PDT 2007


Cmon people you could at least pretend that you are aware of some of this history; it's really alienating. FDR wasn't such a tough guy when it came to facing the Southern Democrats. Also the question of why there was no new deal for immigration with restrictions extended to Philipinos by FDR and continued repatriation of 'Mexicans', including the American born. Rakesh

http://www.motherjones.com/arts/books/2005/09/the_great_white_way.html

While European immigrants got the racial stamp of approval, the federal government was engaged in a little-recognized piece of racial rigging that resulted in both FDR's New Deal and Truman's Fair Deal being set up largely for the benefit of whites. As Ira Katznelson explains in When Affirmative Action Was White, these transformative public programs, from Social Security to the GI Bill, were deeply—and intentionally—discriminatory. Faced with a de facto veto by Southern Democrats, throughout the 1930s and 1940s Northern liberals acquiesced to calls for "states' rights" as they drafted the landmark laws that would create a new white middle class. As first-generation white immigrants cashed in on life-altering benefits, black families who had been here since Revolutionary times were left out in the cold.

Disbursement of federal Depression relief was left at the local level, so that Southern blacks were denied benefits and their labor kept at serf status. In parts of Georgia, no blacks received emergency relief; in Mississippi, less than 1 percent did. Agricultural and domestic workers were excluded from the new Social Security system, subjecting 60 percent of blacks (and 75 percent of Southern blacks) to what Katznelson calls "a form of policy apartheid" far from what FDR had envisioned. Until the 1950s, most blacks remained ineligible for Social Security. Even across the North, black veterans' mortgage, education, and housing benefits lagged behind whites'. Idealized as the capstone of progressive liberalism, such policies were as devastatingly racist as Jim Crow.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list