[lbo-talk] post analytical Marxist era

Charles Brown charlesb at cncl.ci.detroit.mi.us
Tue Sep 25 07:03:49 PDT 2007


The universally developed individuals of Marx's ideal commonwealth are fully autonomous in Kant's sense. This sense is sublated by both

Hegel and Marx. It's found in Hegel's idea of the human "in itself" as a "will proper" and a "universal will." This is a will wholly self-determined by reason.

According to Marx, relations of mutual recognition (an idea of "love"

that, as elaborated by Marx, appropriates Aristotle's idea of "friendship" ("philia")) would constitute the ethical content of a will autonomous in this sense.

So "association" in an ideal commonwealth would necessarily be fully "free"; such association would actualize the ethical content of fully

free, "autonomous" willing and would provide individuals with what each needs to develop this autonomy.

Ted

^^^^^ CB: Doesn't Marx "sublate" or change Aristotle's concept some , too. How could Aristotle guess ahead so many centuries to a personality type that was not possible without the modern proletariat, according to Marx ?



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list