[lbo-talk] Sad Leninism.

Wendy Lyon wendy.lyon at gmail.com
Wed Aug 20 03:39:47 PDT 2008


On 20/08/2008, Gar Lipow <the.typo.boy at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> According to Human Rights Watch, the actual number of deaths at the
> hands of Georgian troops is more like 44 than 1,500 to 2,000.
> http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/aug/13/georgia

There is a discrepancy between the information in that article and what the HRW site itself says. The figures are the same but what they represent is reported differently. The Guardian states it was told by an HRW source that "doctors at Tskhinvali hospital had provided figures that 273 wounded people had been treated there during the conflict and a total of 44 dead people had been brought to the city morgue".

However the HRW site itself says: "A doctor at Tskhinvali Regional Hospital who was on duty from the afternoon of August 7 told Human Rights Watch that between August 6 to12 the hospital treated 273 wounded... The doctor also said that 44 bodies had been brought to the hospital since the fighting began, of both military and civilians. The figure reflects only those killed in the city of Tskhinvali. But the doctor was adamant that the majority of people killed in the city had been brought to the hospital before being buried, because the city morgue was not functioning due to the lack of electricity in the city." http://www.hrw.org/english/docs/2008/08/13/russia19620.htm

Assuming the latter is the more accurate, in addition to the 44 brought to the hospital there are probably: - people killed outside of Tskhinvali - people who were not brought to the hospital (adamant or not, the doctor can't be certain there weren't any) - people who have died of their injuries since this doctor was spoken to

Agreed that these extra figures are unlikely to reach the 1500-2000 mark but, certainly, they would push it up well over 44.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list