[lbo-talk] Klein's work (was Re: Jezebel does Naomi Klein)

Shane Taylor shane.taylor at verizon.net
Tue Dec 2 18:22:59 PST 2008


Peter Ward wrote:


> But so what? The author isn't concerned with
> the problems of the left, in fact in some
> sense is acting in opposition to the left.
> It's not relevant to the value Klein's work
> (whether her claims are true and relevant),
> all that really should matter I would have
> thought.

What is relevant? This reviewer strains to sympathize, but doesn't make a strong sell for the book:

<http://www.chrishayes.org/articles/new-road-serfdom/>

And Doug's review is simply devastating:

<http://leftbusinessobserver.com/Shock.html>

Shane



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list