[lbo-talk] Penn Jillette on global warming

Dwayne Monroe dwayne.monroe at gmail.com
Thu Jul 3 13:34:46 PDT 2008


Jordan:

I will say: I don't think he's making an invalid point when he says "There's a lot of evidence, but global warming encompasses a lot of complicated points: Is it happening? Did we cause it? Is it bad? Can we fix it? Is government-forced conservation the only way to fix it?" ... I certainly haven't seen "scientific consensus" lined up behind the answers to any of these questions except the first one, which I believe he's using as an anchor.

[...]

.............

Sure, that sounds right.

But I think those other questions -- the ones beyond "is it happening?" -- are best answered by policy we're only getting in half-assed form and via engineering projects which should be global in scope but which are now mostly scattered and uncoordinated.

At least one scientist has tried to address this:

Sustainable Energy - Without the Hot Air

<http://www.withouthotair.com/>

Jordan again:

So really, he's just the wrong person to ask; because his approach is to criticise the stupid-low-hanging-fruit rather than give a balanced reading of all the points. Hey, he's a (great) magician and a (pretty good, sometimes) comedian; who gives a fuck what he thinks about global warming?

Least of all: him.

..........

Yup.

.d.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list