[lbo-talk] "Theory's Empire," an anti-"Theory" anthology

Charles Brown charlesb at cncl.ci.detroit.mi.us
Tue May 27 14:47:14 PDT 2008



>>> "Jerry Monaco"

One should distinguish the many uses of the term "theory" of course and probably others have discussed this.

^^^ CB: Materialism vs idealism here derives from Engels' discussion in _Ludwig Feurbach_ of philosophy(see below). Engels attitude toward philosophy is scientific. So, "theory" here is as in scientific theories, general principles concerning philosophies. Lenin claimed that the definition of philosophical materialism is the belief in the existence of objective reality.

Frederick Engels Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Part 2: Materialism

http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1886/ludwig-feuerbach/ch02.htm

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The great basic question of all philosophy, especially of more recent philosophy, is that concerning the relation of thinking and being. From the very early times when men, still completely ignorant of the structure of their own bodies, under the stimulus of dream apparitions (1) came to believe that their thinking and sensation were not activities of their bodies, but of a distinct soul which inhabits the body and leaves it at death — from this time men have been driven to reflect about the relation between this soul and the outside world. If, upon death, it took leave of the body and lived on, there was no occasion to invent yet another distinct death for it. Thus arose the idea of immortality, which at that stage of development appeared not at all as a consolation but as a fate against which it was no use fighting, and often enough, as among the Greeks, as a positive misfortune. The quandry arising from the common universal ignorance of what to do with this soul, once its existence had been accepted, after the death of the body, and not religious desire for consolation, led in a general way to the tedious notion of personal immortality. In an exactly similar manner, the first gods arose through the personification of natural forces. And these gods in the further development of religions assumed more and more extramundane form, until finally by a process of abstraction, I might almost say of distillation, occurring naturally in the course of man’s intellectual development, out of the many more or less limited and mutually limiting gods there arose in the minds of men the idea of the one exclusive God of the monotheistic religions.

Thus the question of the relation of thinking to being, the relation of the spirit to nature — the paramount question of the whole of philosophy — has, no less than all religion, its roots in the narrow-minded and ignorant notions of savagery.

This message has been scanned for malware by SurfControl plc. www.surfcontrol.com



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list