I'm less interested in whether one or the other clearly explains what happened (face it: the media are lousy at it) than I am in the question of was at least part of this engineered as a data-point-in-a-series:
"It's a reasonable conclusion; this is an administration that
used the threat of thousands of al-Qaida sleeper cells in the
United States to sell Congress on the Patriot Act, the specter
of mushroom clouds rising over American cities to push through
the Iraq war resolution and the supposedly imminent crash of
the Social Security system to push for privatizing Americans'
retirement savings."
It's certainly true that we live in a world where public opinion is regularly manipulated, but doesn't it trouble you (Doug) that the last half of 2008 was the exact moment that this situation unravelled?
/jordan