[lbo-talk] what's the matter with...

SA s11131978 at gmail.com
Sun Nov 29 04:26:31 PST 2009


Michael Pollak wrote:


> Is it really? Hasn't the (always very poor) hill country voted
> heavily for the anti-poor party ever since the welfare state began?
> They're against central government. And Big Government party is
> always, by definition, the poor people party.

Didn't West Virginia vote Democrat religiously since the 1930's? And in the civil war era, these areas were strongly Republican, I believe, which was the party of centralizing government (though not, of course, of the welfare state). I can see how yokels might be "traditionally" suspicious of central government, but it seems like there's a common pattern in which at some point in history something changes to make these areas more modern - e.g., reactionary montagnard farmers become proletarianized, find work in mines, get swept up in militant miners' unions, and vote Left unto the generations.

SA



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list