[lbo-talk] Progress/Regress vs Contingency+

Somebody Somebody philos_case at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 10 10:37:01 PDT 2009


Carrol: In the last three centruies, in which the world (or, to beging with, a few spots in the West) were plunged into the hrrible chaos & meaningless ness of capitalism, PROGRESS has come to serve the same purpose that Moira had served for the Greeks. It gives meaning to actions otherwise meaningless.

Somebody: Do people really believe this? There literally isn't a single country in the world, not even in HIV blighted southern Africa, where people don't live longer, healthier lives than in the past. And there isn't a single nation where literacy rates and education levels aren't much higher than they were three centuries ago. Aren't these the sorts of metrics we refer to when praising, for instance, the achievements of the Cuban Revolution? And frankly, even if we want to replace capitalism, isn't the fact that it's supposed to have laid the ground for socialism a kind of progress? 



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list