> At 06:46 AM 1/22/2010, Chris Doss wrote:
>
>
> "Manchester is grimy and deathlike" was a major theme.
>>
>
> I think you can go too far in about 2 seconds with characterizations like
> this but, that said, what do grim, grimy, and deathlike have to do with
> whiny?
>
>
Couldn't that same question be asked about Heartfield's characterization of
Liverpool and the Beatles... geographic determinism is silly, period.