Charles,
Did you read my previous post? The part where I said I'd be happy to engage with you if you read Elbe's text?
Otherwise, no dice. I don't play the "let Charles draw me into a senseless discussion without him reading the article" game.
^^^^^ CB: I read Arthur , and responded with quotes from Marx showing he is wrong, thereby trumping your "Engels and Marx disagreed on the commodity" game. U lose.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------