[lbo-talk] showdown over piece of crap

SA s11131978 at gmail.com
Fri Mar 12 18:01:25 PST 2010


Doug Henwood wrote:


>> Let's not kid ourselves. If the bill doesn't muster the votes in
>> Congress, the administration will shift further to the right as
>> Clinton did after his defeat, and demoralized Democratic voters will
>> tilt the country further rightwards by ushering in a Republican
>> dominated legislature.
>
> So let's tilt right, lest we tilt right?

Just a point of clarification: There are two different questions that should be kept separate - (1) whether the bill represents a victory for liberals/the left/progressives; and (2) whether right now it would be better for the bill to pass or to be defeated. For me, the answer to (1) is clearly no. But that doesn't imply any particular answer as to (2).

Personally, I don't find (2) to be a particularly interesting or fruitful question.

SA



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list