[lbo-talk] as if on cue

c b cb31450 at gmail.com
Mon Jan 31 09:35:35 PST 2011


Shane Mage


>>> before 1939 few believed that the nation of Bach and Goethe will be
>>> overrun by barbaric mass murderers.
>>
>> There was never a "nation of Bach and Goethe."...
>>
>> ...In fact, 1871 is only 77 years before 1948 in historical time, a
>> mere blip,
>> but somehow some nations are more "natural" than others.

The German *state* dates from 1871. The German nation is more than a few centuries older than that. It ill becomes someone who doesn't even know the difference between a *state* and a *nation* to use the word "moron."

^^^^^^^ CB: Yeah. the German nation is somewhat co-terminus with speakers of the German language.

As for Europe's roots in Greece, how come so much of modern European medical vocabulary consists in Greek words if some roots of modern Europe aren't in ancient Greeece ? Why are European university classical studies of Greece and Rome ?



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list