It even works when the assumed grounds for the judgment are false. That is, there are many grounds for questioning the Monthly Review analysis on many occasions. Their attempts to locate a direct economic motive for the war on the Vietnamese people were almost risible; their judgment of the war was clearly accurate.
Carrol
On 6/21/2011 6:45 PM, Chuck Grimes wrote:
>
> Moves to limit economic protests and labour strikes are ongoing in
> Egypt and Tunisia. Once elections are held to bring about a new class
> of servants of the new order, we will hear that all economic demands
> should be considered `counterrevolutionary'and should be prosecuted
> for attempting to `weaken' if not `destroy' the new `democracy'. If,
> as is becoming more apparent, the US strikes alliances with local
> Islamist parties, we might even hear that economic protests and
> opposition to neoliberal imperial economic policies are `against
> Islam.' The US-imposed `democracy' to come, assuming even a semblance
> of it will be instituted, is precisely engineered to keep the poor
> down and to delegitimise all their economic demands. The exchange that
> the US hopes to achieve by imposing some form of liberal political
> order on Egypt and Tunisia is indeed more, not less, imperial pillage
> of their economies and of the livelihoods of their poor classes, who
> are the large majority of the population. The ultimate US aim then is
> to hijack the successful uprisings against the existing regimes under
> the cover of democracy for the benefit of the very same local and
> international business elites in power under Mubarak and Ben Ali. How
> successful the US and its local allies will be will depend on the
> Egyptian and Tunisian peoples.
>
> http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/opinion/2011/06/2011689456174295.html
>
>
> Joseph Massad who wrote the above essay teaches at Columbia. He might
> make for a good interview on Behind the News.
>
> The above was also my thought or worry about the Egyptians. But while
> I was watching, a fair number of those interviewed seemed fully aware
> of these manipulations by the US and EU.
>
> CG
> ___________________________________
> http://mailman.lbo-talk.org/mailman/listinfo/lbo-talk