[lbo-talk] vaca reading

c b cb31450 at gmail.com
Fri May 13 05:51:41 PDT 2011


Angelus Novus Carrol wrote:


> He was a staunch follower of the pre-1914 Kautsky

This is correct. Not only that, but Lenin also took Kautsky's position *against* Rosa Luxemburg during the "mass strike" debate within the SPD.

I'd like to think that Lenin's support for soviet power in 1917 represents an implicit revision of his position vis-a-vis Luxemburg, but does anyone know of any actual texts where he revises his position in favor of Luxemburg and against Kautsky?

^^^^^^^ CB: You should probably take the emphatic criticism of Kautsky in _The State and Revolution_ ( "renegade" and "ex-Marxist") as a somewhat more explicit revision of his position vis-a-vis Luxemburg generally then, but more looking to now and forward than backward. Concrete analysis of the concrete situation doesn't involve much revisiting analyses of the past and revising them.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list