[lbo-talk] Essential Reading - Hah!

Dennis Claxton ddclaxton at earthlink.net
Sun Feb 5 03:21:41 PST 2012


-----Original Message-----
>From: Carrol Cox <cbcox at ilstu.edu>


>6 (7?) billion people. We do not know for what proportion of them reading
>and writing (regardless of training) can or will be a _comfortable_
>activity. And for billions now it is not in fact comfortable. Are you
>denying them the capacity for happiness unless they learn to read and write?

Come on Carrol. I'm not going to drag out my logic manual, but there are at least two more than one logical fallacy in this response.

I'll play though. People have asked you this before and as far as I know you've never responded. Why did you study literature? And I'll go you one further. Why do people on this list, generally speaking, love your posts about literature better than most of your other posts (unscientific finding of course.)?



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list