[lbo-talk] School Debate: Central Focus

Dennis Claxton ddclaxton at earthlink.net
Wed Feb 15 14:54:56 PST 2012



> > Dennis Claxton writes: 'Just as a machine is seen as an alien
> thing by the worker, and the normal and necessary activity of labor
> is converted into a horror, so too is much of schooling. Everything
> that might be good is turned into an evil. But surely machines and
> labor and reading and writing are not inherently evil. Surely a
> good argument can be made that all are fundamental.'
> >
> > Which is a good analogy, and well put, I think.

That was Michael Yates, not me. As was this in M. Smith's earlier post:

> Just because schools in the United States are a

> form of torment for so many students, essentially

> vehicles for indoctrination and preparation for a

> lifetime of meaningless work doesn't mean that

> learning to read and write are not necessary for

> both survival and happiness in the modern world

> and further could be seen as enjoyable by the

> overwhelming majority of persons.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list