CoCC sez...

Max Sawicky sawicky at epinet.org
Mon Mar 1 10:00:05 PST 1999



> Re Max's: "I wouldn't say all
> murder should be punishable by death, but some should
> be, as far
> as I'm concerned."
>
> I am opposed to capital punishing, but the killing of
> James Byrd so
> sickened me that I thought this might be one instance
> where the death
> penalty would be a good idea.

But this case isn't all that unusual. Down here in D.C., a man hired a hit-man to kill his invalid son for the insurance money (the kid was on assorted life-support machines). The hit-man murdered the baby-sitter and then yanked the child's oxygen supply. What can people like this deserve?

The Byrd case got a lot of publicity because of some sensationalist details, as well as for the racial dimension, but to me it is not different than, say, a sniper taking someone out cleanly with one shot.

We seem to apportion blame and possible punishment based on secondary characteristics of the victim(s) and perpetrators, rather on the fundamental matters of the mental state of the killer, his/her remorse or lack thereof, and the basic fact of the death of an innocent person.

mbs



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list