'Identity Politics'

rc-am rcollins at netlink.com.au
Fri Sep 17 21:57:48 PDT 1999


dennis,

actually, the first is a gillian rose translation from _Jargon of Authenticity_ , p.26 [my notes are unclear]; or if you prefer, p. 430 from the _Gesamelte Shriften_, volume 6. rose's notation suggests that 'security' should be translated as 'shelterdness', from _geborgenheit_, but decides this is unwieldy and unecessary.

the second citation is from _negative dialectics_, p216-17 in the ashton translation, p.216 in the german. dennis, you'll know better than me if the translation of this particular passage does much damage.

dennis also quoth:


> Also, for Adornophiles, another mindbending gem from pp. 17-18 of
Negative Dialectics (German edition): "The contradiction is the non-identical under the aspect of identity; the primacy of the principle of contradiction in dialectics yields the heterogenous within unitary thinking. By colliding against its own borders, it reaches beyond itself. Dialectics is the consequent consciousness of non-identity... Identity and contradiction in thinking are welded to one another. The totality of the contradiction is nothing less than the untruth of the total identification, as this is manifested in itself. Contradiction is non-identity under the spell of the law, which also influences the non-identical." ND:17-18<

which perhaps is another way of saying that any given dialectic is not indeed overcome by taking one side of any given dialectic as the accomplishment of , or the line of, a transcendance in thought?

Angela _________



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list