[PEN-L:6419] Defending Martyrs,Reclaiming Memory & History (was Re: Leonard Peltier + Working within thesystem)

Carrol Cox cbcox at ilstu.edu
Tue Dec 19 21:24:26 PST 2000


Yoshie Furuhashi wrote:


>
> It is not the case that the Left prefers an association with violence
> to non-violence. The Left -- or _any other political force_ for that
> matter -- makes a cause out of *martyrs* . . .

A tentative suggestion. I've always sort of acted from the slogan, We will accept casualties but we will not be martyrs. We would rather win Mumia's freedom than celebrate him as a martyr.

This is, I fear, against the grain of the language as used, but I thought I would toss it in. I tend to associate "martyr" with Christian Martyrs, with many of whom I have little sympathy. We want to destroy capitalism and build socialism, not merely bear witness to that desire.

But in any case the need to recapture and preserve our history is core, as Yoshie says. Solidarity must extend in time as well as in space or it loses its grip on us.

Carrol



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list