Naderites Craft "Fix It or Nix It" Campaign

Rakesh Bhandari bhandari at phoenix.Princeton.EDU
Sun Jan 2 11:37:34 PST 2000


Nathan noted:


> Marx thought Bismarck was an improvement over
> the localized principalities he replaced, if only by focusing worker
> energy on a more unified target

While this would seem to be an argument for the strengthening of the WTO governing body--an ostensibly more unified target-- I would like to point out that Marx fought tooth and nail Lassalle's cooperation with Bismarck--though this does not speak to the point Nathan is making here.

However, Lassalle's social democracy resembles Nathan's. From his Bastiat Schulze: " There is no *social way* that leads out of this social situation. The vain efforts of *things* to behave like *human beings* can be seen in the English strikes whose melancholy outcome is familiar enough. *The only way* out for the workers is to be found in *that* sphere *within which* they can be still be human beings, i.e., *the state.* Hence the instinctive but infinite hatred which the liberal bourgeoisie bears the concept of the state in its every manifestation." Quoted in Lukacs' History and Class Consciousness, p. 195

I will have to revisit the Hal Draper volumes to get straight Marx's critique of Lassalle's crediting of the state with a completely utopian function, wholly alien to its concrete character. Needless to say, Marx drew a straight line from state fetishism to Lassalle's policy of adventurous illusions in Bismarck. Will need to revisit John MacGuire's book on Marx's Theory of Politics

Happy new year, everyone!

RB



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list