Spinoza on Women's Subordination to Men

Michael Hoover hoov at freenet.tlh.fl.us
Mon Mar 20 18:53:22 PST 2000


"But, perhaps, someone will ask, whether women are under men's authority by nature or institution? If it has been by mere institution, then we had no reason compelling us to exclude women from government. But if we consult *experience* itself, we shall find that the origin of it is in their weakness. For there has never been a case of men and women reigning together, but wherever on the earth men are found, there we see that men rule, and women are ruled, and that on this plan, both sexes live, in harmony. But on the other hand, the Amazons, who are reported to have held rule of old, did not suffer men to stop in their country, but reared only their female children, by killing males to whom they gave birth. But if by nature women were equal to men, and were equally distinguished by force of character and ability, in which human power and therefore human right chiefly consist; surely among nations so many and different some would be found, where both sexes rule alike, and others where, where men are ruled by women, and so brought up, that they can make less use of their abilities. And since this is nowhere the case, one may assert with perfect propriety, that women have not by nature equal right with men; but that they necessarily give way to men, and that thus is cannot happen that both sexes should rule alike, much less that men should be ruled by women. But if we further reflect upon human passions, how men, in fact, generally love women merely from passion of lust, and esteem their cleverness and wisdom in proportion to the excellence of their beauty, and also show how very ill-disposed men are to suffer the women they love to show any sort of favor to other, and other facts of this kind, we shall easily see that men and women cannot rule alike without great hurt to peace." _A Theologico-Political Treatise and Political Treatise_, translated by R. H. Melwes, Dover Publications, 1955, pp. 386-387.

Michael Hoover



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list