mental space

[kelley]

At 03:33 PM 11/29/00 -0600, Carrol Cox wrote:
>This is clearly one of those cases in which the whole
>argument consists in the vague suggestiveness of
>one word -- scientistic. By scientistic the author
>clearly means whatever doesn't agree with his
>preconceived notions.
>
>People who can't argue without the use of this bit
>of jargon are seldom worth reading.
>
>Carrol

you might consider reading the whole thing carrol in stead of dismissing 
outright.  there were some interesting issues raised, even on my quick 
skim.  some of the things the author addressed were the very concerns you 
raise.

kelley