Said on American Zionism

brettk at brettk at
Mon Oct 16 10:42:42 PDT 2000


Concerning your criticism of the Palestinians for not taking the Ghandi-road...

Chomsky actually addresses this. In one of the passages in the Chomsky Reader (don't have it with me - I'll provide details tomorrow) he talks about a Palestinian town that did precisely this - staged peaceful demonstrations and non-violent protests against the Israelis. They got zero international support, and were violently pushed aside.

The point is, the "Ghandi-road" only works if you get observers to pressure the oppressors. If your plight goes unreported, or others don't care, it gets you nowhere, and is doomed to failure.

>Well, it *is* the only democracy in the region, and when you compare
>even a Binyamin Netanyahu to a Hafez Assad there does seem to be a
>very clear difference. More important, however, is that a lot of
>American Jews care enough about Israel to make it them single-issue
>voters, and a lot of non-Jews feel responsible for the failure of the
>U.S. to have prevented the extermination of half the world's Jews
>between 1941 and 1945...

Why should people in the US feel responsible for the holocaust? The Nazi's, not the Americans, were exterminating Jews. I've never understood this position.


More information about the lbo-talk mailing list