Survivor!

Lisa & Ian Murray seamus at accessone.com
Tue Oct 31 11:53:59 PST 2000



>>That is, groups of altruists or even reciprocal altruists replace(i.e.
eliminate through natural selection) groups of egoists provided that group selectionist pressures are stronger than individual selection pressures. *Unto Others* by Sober and Wilson is the locus classicus in the philosophical, psychological and biological refutation of egoism and individualism.

Sam Pawlett *********

The larger question is whether the selection "mechanisms" would be stable enough to prevent the re-emergence of egoists, given the improbability of NS wiping them out. One can't refute egoism any more than one can refute capitalism.

Darwin's quote is the perfect apologia for imperialism and racism. Isn't the quest for advantage itself antithetical to altruism? Also to the extent that altruists are "locked in" to a struggle against egoists, isn't that, too, just a different form of social Darwinism?

Ian



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list