Kendall Clark wrote:
>
> >>>>> "marta" == Marta Russell <ap888 at lafn.org> writes:
>
> marta> We had a lengthy discussion of Singer on this list. It's in
> marta> the archives. You'll see a lengthy discussion of Singer's
> marta> position on disability. He does attribute a negative value
> marta> to disabled lives.
>
> No he doesn't. That's simply false.
>
Yes he does. He acknowledged that in a debate with Adrianne Asch at Princeton.
>
> If that's the upshot of the 'lengthy' discussion about Singer on this
> list, it certainly wasn't a *good* discussion.
>
Why don't you read the past discussion first cause you don't know what
you speak about.
I don't have the time to recount it all for you.
marta