Black Prisoner of War

Yoshie Furuhashi furuhashi.1 at
Sun May 20 03:48:23 PDT 2001

Black Prisoner of War

A Conscientious Objector's Vietnam Memoir

James A. Daly and Lee Bergman

Introduction by Jeff Loeb

October 2000 312 pages, 13 photographs, 6 x 9 Modern War Studies Cloth ISBN 0-7006-1059-6, $40.00 Paper ISBN 0-7006-1060-X, $17.95

Black Prisoner of War chronicles the story of James Daly, a young black soldier held captive for more than five years by the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese and subsequently accused (and acquitted) of collaboration with the enemy. One of the very few books about the Vietnam War by an African American, Daly's memoir is both a testament to survival and a provocative meditation on the struggle between patriotism and religious conviction.

First published in 1975 as A Hero's Welcome, Daly's memoir had only a brief exposure before it sank from sight. At the time, most Americans simply wanted to forget about the war. But, as Jeff Loeb argues, Daly's story is a compelling one that merits a much wider readership.

Raised in Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant area, Daly fought to overcome difficult circumstances through hard work and religion. When the Vietnam War intervened, he was denied conscientious objector status, despite his strong pacifist beliefs. He then enlisted in the U.S. Army, but only after a black recruiter assured him he would receive a non-combat assignment. Instead, he was sent to fight in Vietnam, where he was denied repeated requests for reassignment. In protest, he refused to load or fire his weapon, even when sent out on patrol.

When his unit was ambushed by the Viet Cong, he began his long ordeal in captivity, first in the jungles of South Vietnam and then in the infamous "Hanoi Hilton." As a POW, he was still an outcast: a black "grunt" and pacifist among mostly white air force officers who considered any sort of accommodation treasonable. Such charges were eventually leveled at Daly for joining the so-called Peace Committee and signing a letter condemning American actions in the war. Although Daly's decisions were in keeping with his pacifism and he was later cleared of the charges, he remains a controversial figure for many Vietnam veterans.

Exploring the limits of both accommodation and resistance, Daly's memoir forces us to reassess the POW experience and race relations in Vietnam, as well as the complex relationship between personal belief and public duty.

"A fascinating memoir that offers a unique perspective on events that have been contested in American culture for decades. . . . An astonishing treasure chest filled with priceless gems of insight."--H. Bruce Franklin, author of M.I.A.: Mythmaking in America

"An important account that illustrates the profound moral, ethical, and intellectual dilemmas faced by many of the young men of Daly's generation."--James E. Westheider, author of Fighting on Two Fronts: African Americans and the Vietnam War

"An honest and moving account."--Christian Science Monitor

JAMES A. DALY (1946?1998) served with Alpha Company of the 196th Light Infantry Brigade. After the war, he worked for the U.S. Postal Service for nearly two decades.

LEE BERGMAN, a novelist and biographer who lives in New York, is a former member of the Armed Forces Press Service.

JEFF LOEB, a former Marine who served in Vietnam during 1968 and 1969, is the author of numerous articles in journals such as African American Review and American Studies and editor of Terry Whitmore's Memphis-Nam-Sweden: The Autobiography of a Black American Exile.

©2000 University Press of Kansas 2501 West 15th St., Lawrence, KS 66049 Phone (785) 864-4155; Fax (785) 864-4586


More information about the lbo-talk mailing list