On Selective Pacifism & other Oddities

Luke Weiger lweiger at umich.edu
Thu Nov 29 11:35:16 PST 2001



> I don't get it. If I oppose _this_ war, I have to oppose _every_ war? Why?
> What's wrong with traditional just war theory, taught at the Point and
> Annapolis, under which it can beargued that some wars, e.g., the wara
gainst
> the Nazis. is just, but some other wars, like the US invasion of Vietnam,
or
> theSoviet invasion of Afghanistan, or this war, is unjust? jks

Max is (correctly) pointing out that many non-pacifist leftists use arguments that are de facto pacifistic (because they apply to all wars) to justify their opposition. To put a Schwartzian query to you, what's there not to get?

-- Luke



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list