narratives

[Max B. Sawicky]

Not in this context.  It's hard to imagine Israeli
troops going over to the other side or, in light of
armed opposition, refusing to fire their guns.

Your scenarios derive from cases where the troops
and the insurgents are much closer in identity than
zionists and palestinian nationalists.

Dealing with violence at or below the level of
rock-throwing is another matter, but in that case
you don't really have armed struggle, which was my
point.

And how could a critic of armed struggle be anything
but 'armchair'?  At any rate, there are actually a lot
of armchairs I can't fit into.

mbs

Max Sawicky wrote:
>
>
> Military victory of Palestine through armed struggle is clearly a fantasy,

You are romanticizing armed struggle.

-