Israel Shamir: the beginning of the end of the Jewish post-war ascendancy?

kjkhoo at softhome.net kjkhoo at softhome.net
Sat Apr 27 09:25:47 PDT 2002


At 8:11 pm -0700 26/4/02, Michael Pugliese wrote:
>were reprinting that junk without checking out the bona fides of the
>author.

huh? surely junk is junk, irrespective of the bona fides of the author. contrariwise, if something is good, it's good regardless of the bona fides of the author.


> We should take our cues from Ali Abunimah and Hussein Ibish. They
>aren't the type to utter inflamotory sloganizing like Zionazism.

Curiously, in a report in the Apr 26 Guardian (UK) regarding the destruction of infrastructure and equipment, an Israeli army spokesman, Captain Ron Edelheit was quoted as saying: "The human rights organisations are not always fair, blonde, blue-eyed European".

Wow! The last time I looked, it was in the name of "fair, blonde blue-eyed Europeans" that Jews were exterminated.

Now along comes an Israeli army spokesman distinguishing between fair blond blue-eyed European human rights organisations and those others.

Then earlier on in the year, there was that piece from one of the 'refuseniks' in which he quoted some Israeli army person talking about learning from the methods of Germans in the Warsaw Ghetto...

Perhaps indeed zionazism might need another take ;)


>*Well not entirely...
>http://csf.colorado.edu/mail/psn/2002/msg01124.html
>Re: Palestinian Holocaust Denial
>by Michael Pugliese
>16 April 2002 19:02 UTC

It is perhaps noteworthy that Palestinian and Arab Holocaust denial is derivative -- the junk that Euro-America throws up gets swallowed and re-gurgitated.

I do not know, but perhaps someone here does -- when did Holocaust denial become a significant strand in Palestinian/Arab politics? Is it a case of having something thrown in your face so often that the gut response is to try and deny it? Doesn't make it right, although I can well understand it. Like my gut response to the (re-?)discovery of 'culture' and 'development' is to deny it, despite (or perhaps because of) the wondrous 'rehabilitation' of confucianism...

kj khoo



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list