More on police work

andie nachgeborenen andie_nachgeborenen at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 4 06:23:28 PST 2002


I don't
> >make any apologies or excuses for al Qaida's
> crimes.
> >But my loathing for Jeffrey Dahmer (to use Luke's
> >analogy) doesn't mean that I'm throwing my hand in
> >with Murder Inc.
>

I conclude that police investigation is in
> >order to deal with crimes, but social upheaval is
> necessary to deal with a psychotic superpower.


> ----
> Isn't calling for a police investigation "throwing
> in your hand" with Murder Inc.?
> Instead of calling for a police investigation -
> after all, the Vietnam war was a
> "police action", why not highlight the crimes of
> Empire and its double standards?

Why Either/Or? We do need social critique and social upheaval to deal with imperialism. But we do need to do something to deal the thugs in al Qaida. Unlike some here, perhaps, I think that the police--I don't mean the military figfhting wars and calling them police actions, but the cops and the FBI--serve a legitimate and necessary crime fighting function. There are bad guys out there who belong in jail. Al Qaida is among them. I say let the cops track 'em down and put 'em away, contrained by all the usual rules of due process. If they stuck to that sort of thing, the govt would be a lot less like Murder Inc.

But since you reject any use of state power to deal with any crime, however horrific, what is your suggestion about what to do with al Qaida? Maybe, have a social revolution here, dismantle imperialism, and thus leave it without reason to attack us? But maybe they will not like a socialist secular America either, and the revolution is not exactly immanent anyway. So should we just say, que sera, sera, serves us right, death to Empire? That'll make us real popularw ith the working class, I'll tell you.

jks
> PEter
>
>
>

__________________________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now. http://mailplus.yahoo.com



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list