Who Does No Work, Shall Not Eat

Gordon Fitch gcf at panix.com
Mon Jan 21 12:07:13 PST 2002



>>> thats an interesting point too, isnt it? i think the biologist
>>> lewontin has a piece where he traces lots of advances in public health
>>> to such thing as sanitation and sewage systems rather than advances in
>>> western medicine.

Brad DeLong wrote:
> >If Lewontin thinks that sewage, sanitation, and the rest of public
> >health are not part of "western medicine," then he is one whacked-out
> >dude indeed...

ravi:
> first, before we start bad-mouthing poor prof. lewontin, let me say that
> the above is my no doubt flawed recollection of his writings, so if you
> need to call someone names, aim your invectives at me! ;-)
>
> i think you are off on a tangent here. i can agree with you that sewage
> etc are a *part of* "western medicine" and avoid the deviation.

I don't know about Lewontin, but I've read descriptions of elaborate water and sewage systems which existed in the ancient world. As far as I know, the savants and governors of the West did not adopt such things until the 19th century, somewhat late in the day.

-- Gordon



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list